Why not physical punishment
The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) and the WHO advise against physical punishment such as spanking and against harsh verbal punishment such as insults and threats. Physical punishment may stop a behavior in the moment, but the effect does not last, and it is linked to more aggressive behavior, anxiety and a worse parent-child relationship. Children learn that bigger people may hit.
In Korea, the parental "disciplinary right" clause (Article 915) was deleted from the Civil Code in January 2021. This means hitting a child cannot be justified as discipline, even by a parent. Korea's Child Welfare Act also prohibits physical and emotional abuse of children.
Positive discipline basics
- Relationship first: discipline works when there is a store of everyday play and eye contact.
- Clear limits: keep must-follow rules (safety, respecting others) few, and keep them consistently.
- Give warnings: announce what comes next, like "in 5 minutes we'll tidy up the toys."
- Say what to do instead of what not to do: "walk inside" rather than "don't run."
- Specific praise: name the behavior, like "you let your sister go first," instead of just "good job."
- Offer choices: let your child choose within acceptable options, like "the red cup or the blue cup?"
- Natural and logical consequences: use results tied to the behavior, such as putting away a toy for a while after it is thrown.
Discipline by age
- Around 1 to 2 years: rather than explanations, physically moving your child away from danger, redirecting and changing the environment (removing hazards) work best.
- Ages 2 to 3: tantrums are common. State rules in short, simple words, accept feelings but hold the limit on behavior. A time-out to calm down, or a time-in where you stay close, can help.
- Ages 4 to 6: explain reasons and make rules together. Give responsibilities such as tidying and simple chores.
- Elementary school: agree on rules and consequences in advance, and solve problems together when they come up. Respectful two-way conversation becomes important.
Five steps of emotion coaching
Emotion coaching means accepting all of a child's feelings while setting limits on behavior. Children whose feelings are understood calm down faster and learn to express feelings in words.
- 1. Notice: read the emotion in your child's face and behavior.
- 2. See an opportunity: treat emotional moments as chances to connect and teach.
- 3. Listen with empathy: listen without judgment, like "you were really upset."
- 4. Name the feeling: help your child put words to feelings such as anger, disappointment or jealousy.
- 5. Set limits and solve problems together: "It's okay to be angry, but hitting is not okay. What could you do instead?"
Handling tantrums and hitting
- Tantrums are a common part of development between ages 1 and 4. First check for causes like hunger or tiredness.
- Keep your child safe, and keep your voice low and calm. Long explanations do not work mid-meltdown.
- Hold the limit consistently so your child does not learn that tantrums get results.
- If your child hits or bites, stop it right away and firmly ("we don't hit people"), then once calm, practice putting feelings into words.
- Afterward, give a hug and repair the connection.
When parents are worn out
When anger rises, make sure your child is safe and step away for a moment to breathe. Lack of sleep, depression and stress lower anyone's patience. Do not carry it alone: share the load with a partner or family. In Korea, local childcare support centers offer parenting education and counseling, and community mental health welfare centers can help too.
FAQ
Is even a light spank on the bottom not okay?
The AAP and WHO do not recommend even mild physical punishment, because the effect does not last and it is linked to aggression. In 2021, Korea deleted the parental disciplinary right clause from its Civil Code.
Are time-outs okay?
The AAP describes brief time-outs as an alternative to physical punishment. Use them as a time to calm down rather than as a scare, and be warm again when it ends. For young children, staying close beside them may fit better.
My child lies on the floor screaming in the store.
Move your child somewhere safe and wait calmly. If a tantrum gets them the item, it is likely to happen again. Telling them the rules before going out also helps.
Won't accepting every feeling spoil my child?
Accepting feelings is different from allowing behavior. Emotion coaching acknowledges feelings while clearly holding limits on behavior, such as "hitting is not okay."
Sources
- AAP HealthyChildren.org (effective discipline)
- AAP policy statement: Effective Discipline to Raise Healthy Children (2018)
- WHO fact sheet on corporal punishment of children
- Korean Civil Code Article 915 (disciplinary right clause deleted, 2021)
- Korea's Ministry of Health and Welfare and National Center for the Rights of the Child
Medical information is for reference only. This is general information and does not replace diagnosis or treatment. Always talk to your child's doctor. In an emergency in Korea, call 119.
Related
Children begin speaking in sentences and playing pretend. They leave diapers behind, learn to get along with peers, and ask 'Why?' constantly.
Age 4โ5Ages 4โ5Children make up stories and start rule-based games with friends. Before elementary school, it's time for booster shots and the last infant checkups.
Age 6โ7Ages 6โ7 (starting elementary school)A big transition from kindergarten to school. Managing on their own and getting used to the school rhythm matter more than letters and numbers.
19โ24 mo19โ24 monthsWords and willpower grow together. Many toddlers start joining two words, and 'I do it!' becomes common. The checkup around the second birthday is a good time to review development.
Dads and Shared ParentingA dad is not a "helper" but a parent raising the child together. The care skills you build in the first few weeks shape how parenting is shared for years.
Postpartum Recovery and Postpartum DepressionThe weeks and months after birth are a time when body and mind recover together. Struggling is not a sign of weakness, and asking for help is also something you do for your baby.